to put an end to the "youth movement"
Introduction: Here we are!
It would seem that here we are... The meeting of Gen Z and the gilets jaunes, the centre of Paris ravaged, the demonstrators a pinch away from entering into the Elysée, the world of employment finally following with a call to general strike, the word revolution in every mouth and a revolutionary movement that seems to stretch all over Europe.
But something isn't right. This list isn't exactly false, but without being able to say exactly why, it’s clear that it doesn’t reflect the actual experience of all those who have dedicated themselves to this movement since the very first high school was blockaded. How can we explain this strange gap? Of course there are things missing from the list: friends in jail, humiliating demonstration routes, the horrible activist route that takes its course, the real role of trade unions in social war, bewilderment in the face of victory...
However, in this text I want to address one of the main reasons we are, in my opinion, being swept away by the counter-insurrection again: the réjouissance over the emergence of a "youth movement". To relate to the current situation as a youth movement stops us from relating to it as a revolutionary moment. Even if all of this is true in many respects, the tendency to portray youth as synonymous with “freshness,” “passion,” “rejection of the old world,” and so on stems from a failure to understand what has driven contemporary revolts, the specific situation in France today, and what makes a revolutionary moment in general. This incomprehension and the weighted emphasis on solidarity in the current struggle gives rise to phenomena of delegation of a combat to be waged which weakens us considerably. If solidarity represents, for a lot of people, the only resource left in the face of the general impoverishment [pauperisation] of the population and to the extreme violence of capital, in this context it takes on an inhibitory direction. The signifier “youth” serves up on a silver platter the idea of an avant-garde that one cannot help but support, while at the same time being associated with the image of an ideal revolutionary subject who possesses a very particular capacity for revolt. These false representations support something which stops other people from acting and finding their place in the movement underway.
This comes of three ideas to be deconstructed:
1. The revolts of Gen Z and the revolts of youth
Thanks to the revolts of GenZ we've seen the return of the idea by which 'youth' would be the revolutionary subject par excellence. And we understand why: since 2022 particularly inspiring revolts made revolutionaries' hearts vibrate the world over and seem to incarnate the revolutionary form par excellence of the years to come.
In 2022, in Sri Lanka, mass demonstrations coupled with a wave of occupations of official building going as far as the occupation of the president Gotabaya Rajapaksa's residence led to his destitution and flight from the country. In Bangladesh in July 2024, the prime minister Sheikh Hasina met with the same fate, after a month of riots stemming from the abolition of the hiring quota system in the civil service, which had become a symbol of the ruling oligarchy. In Indonesia, the country erupts in violence after the police kill a young delivery driver, Affan Kurniawan. The government manages to hold on to power, but this uprising leads to the formation of an anarchist movement that is now gaining increasing momentum. In Nepal, in September 2025, the parliament is set ablaze and the government is ousted following a day of massive riots sparked by a shutdown of social media networks aimed at stifling criticism of the lavish lifestyles of the children of government officials. In Madagascar, too, the government is ousted by a movement that originated in nationwide power outages and increasingly difficult access to water. Finally, in Morocco, the deaths of eight women in childbirth at the Agadir hospital in September 2025 spark a mass protest movement that nearly brings down the government.
The revolts were led by the young, undeniably. But that doesn't mean simply that the participants were young, but rather that they expressed something of a shared condition, in the reasons of their anger as well as in their practical actions. The OnePiece flag is the most obvious symbol of this but we can also see it in the investment of the question of informal work for example (the condition of delivery drivers, jobs linked to applications [platform capitalism] etc) or in the use of social networks as a space of organisation of the riot or of political discussion.
But the strength of these revolts comes from the fact that these young are the majority of the population in the global south. In Madagascar they represent almost 70% of the population, in Nepal and Indonesia or in Morocco its more than 50%. On top of this, in none of these countries does the part of the population over 65 years old exceed 7%. In France, those under thirty represent 37% of the population and those over 65 22%.
The shared condition of “young people” is therefore, in reality, the condition shared by the entire population, and it must be characterized in a way that goes beyond a mere demographic category. This condition is that of those who have been humiliated, impoverished, abused, and so on. What has been called “youth” in the uprisings of Gen Z is in fact a reflection of the condition that capitalism imposes on the entire population—it is practically a class. This is how we must understand the significance of the denunciation of corruption and the systematic attacks on the residences of ministers and other lawmakers who embody it. For the poorest 99%, it is about taking revenge on the 1%—it’s as simple as that.

"There's 100 million rich in the world for 7 billion poor and we still didn't go fuck them up wallah we're little bitches". [Post on X, France]
To sum up, it was indeed young people who rose up in these uprisings, but it was not because they were young that they were so powerful. It was because they embodied the contradictions of a society in which life had become unbearable. [“Youth” is the term used to describe those who suffer under the new forms of capital accumulation in countries victimized by neocolonialism and whose territory is ravaged by imperialist rivalries. Gen Z thus refers to the widespread certainty that no future is possible in this society. This certainty is not a feeling but the direct experience of the extreme violence of these new forms of capitalism.
In Europe, the situation is therefore quite different. Young people represent a much smaller share of society and enter the labor market later. A sense of meaninglessness is widespread on a global scale, but in old Europe, the form it takes for a large part of the population is that of loss or disappearance. We see this in the old “privileged” professional identities (civil servants, railroad workers, etc.), in republican ideals, and even in the forms of struggle. The spread of conflict in France will also revolve around the specter of trade unionism, social democracy, and the Republic, and the question will be whether to seek to keep them alive or to bury them once and for all.
So we are not witnessing a Gen Z uprising—or rather, Gen Z cannot represent the same force that has been unleashed in the Global South. We live in a country of old people, and our weakness stems from the fact that we’re asking high school students to lead our revolution. If we truly want to overturn the status quo, we must move beyond merely offering support and solidarity and join the struggle that has been ongoing for as long as we’ve been alive—even if we have children.
2. Young People Have Their Whole Future Ahead of Them / Are the Future of the Country
‘Live your… live your… live your life, actually.’ — Makala, LOKETO
The kind of solidarity that inhibits action is spreading everywhere at the moment. It seems to me to rest on the assumption that young people have their whole future ahead of them. Behind all the talk of ‘it's their movement’ or ‘we wouldn't want to speak for the schoolchildren’ lies the same social-democratic logic that leads us to lament ‘the planet we're leaving to our children’, as though we didn't live on it ourselves. We cast young people as the victims of a world yet to come while distancing ourselves from that world, thereby justifying the fact that we've stopped fighting — or never fought in the first place.
We may pity those in their forties, but they still have many years of life ahead of them. Indeed, they are destined to join the dominant group in society: pensioners. In Europe today, we are witnessing a strange reversal of the course of time, in which the old are replacing the young. Schoolchildren and students know perfectly well that they are a dying breed and that soon enough we will all be pensioners. Perhaps that is precisely why they are fighting. On this continent of the living dead, it will become increasingly difficult to find revolutionaries willing to act on our behalf.
We also behave as though youth were a homogeneous category, as though there were no rich and poor young people, no young men and young women, no young Black people and young white people. A sixteen-year-old at a vocational school, destined for a career in construction, will statistically die at the same time as a thirty-five-year-old executive at BNP Paribas. Those who have the future ahead of them today are the ageing bourgeoisie. There is no common future.
And let us not forget that net migration is the only thing keeping the demographic balance in the black. This is the polite way demographers have of saying that, despite militarised borders and the millions of deaths in the Mediterranean, France can only maintain a more or less healthy workforce by admitting enough people destined to join the broad category of Black and Arab people. It is they who will constitute the country's youth in the years to come. Old white men shooting young Black people when they aren't putting them to work: that is Europe's future.
Of course, all this makes us want to stand in solidarity with young people, to whom so little is promised. But we must do more. We must defy this social and racial order and Europe's zombie future. We must not merely support the schoolchildren — we must do as they do! What matters today is that everyone realises their life is not over, that it can still change. If the schoolchildren are inspiring, it is not because they are young but because they are strong. And they are strong because they refuse to put up with things, because they fight back. Today, everyone has a reason to fight back.
‘Eight till six? Well, welcome to real life!’ With this little refrain, right-wing bosses have handed us the best possible reason to revolt. You've been working those hours for twenty years, and not only have you done nothing about it, you're preparing to sign up for another twenty! The lesson of the schoolchildren's movement is that this shitty life is unacceptable, and that we must be prepared to do whatever it takes to put an end to it. Supporting the schoolchildren is yet another way of avoiding the fact that we are already living the very life they are fighting against. We need to act like the schoolchildren, not merely act for them.
3. Young People Have a Unique Capacity for Revolt
In France, even within the autonomous movement, we remain in thrall to the idea, inherited from May '68, that youth itself confers some special, almost magical power to overthrow the system. This both attributes far too much to young people and demands far too much of them. Above all, it means refusing to confront the balance of forces in which we find ourselves. It is a fantasy about youth, not a strategic analysis. For sixty years we have been told that those in power fear young people because they are the future. We are just as quick to imagine that they have a monopoly on joy or violence, without considering that they lack the power to bring the country's economy to a standstill, or that they rarely act alone in insurrectionary situations — as both 17 October and the Yellow Vests movement have shown, to take only the French examples.
I am making a strategic argument here, not asserting a principle. The point is simply that there is almost no chance that university students and schoolchildren, acting alone, will succeed in dealing a serious blow to those in power and sustaining a revolutionary situation, even with anti-repression teams or human chains to protect them. The movement will be transformed only if we can transform our own methods of action and rush into the breach the schoolchildren have opened.
This is obviously not to dismiss the work of providing care and supplies, which has repeatedly helped strengthen the schoolchildren's initiatives, sustain occupations and bring different parts of the movement into contact. But it seems to me that the logic of support is spreading everywhere, to varying degrees. It has become our first instinct whenever we ask ourselves how to engage with the unfolding movement. It prevents other forms of action from emerging and severely limits our capacity for disruption.
The system we live under, and the government that represents it, are on their last legs and within our reach. The old guard have decided to keep them alive. Trade union members have not told their national leaderships to get lost, and have staged just one day of token strike action. Teachers refuse to take up their pupils' struggle, or to acknowledge that schoolchildren are leading the social movement they themselves should have been leading for the past twenty years. Workers sign letters as ‘parents’, sometimes to thank the children for waging a struggle they lack the courage to wage themselves, sometimes to denounce the beatings those children receive. Meanwhile, the white parents' groups in central Paris conveniently overlook the fact that it was not their children who bore the brunt of the unrestrained police violence during the first weeks of the blockades.
And we, the partisans of revolution, must admit that our sixty meetings a week, between groups that already know their disagreements by heart, are hardly equal to the task. In these meetings we identify a lack of support, and yet the question of support invariably creeps back in whenever we ask what we might actually do. We cannot seem to get beyond it.
Once we recognise this pattern as a trap, we have to ask why other forms of action remain so elusive. And this raises another difficult question: how do we come to terms with the defeat of those who have lived through the social movements of the past ten years? Repeated setbacks have taken their toll, as has the absence of any real victories. More generally, bodies and minds are increasingly battered by what passes for the normal course of events. Given the violence we have endured, it would hardly be surprising if solidarity were the only way left for us to relate to the youth uprising. But revolution demands that we defy the odds.
Young people nevertheless possess two particular strengths. The first is their capacity to refuse. The second is the urgency with which the question of the future confronts them — though this question is hardly theirs alone. Their immediate experience of the absence of a future has given them an especially powerful motive for revolt. In organisational terms, however, they have fewer resources than the rest of society.
The responsibility therefore falls to everyone who wants to change the world to bring their capacities for obstruction, destruction, thought and organisation to bear on the construction of a genuine movement, one capable of matching the revolutionary energy displayed by the schoolchildren and on 17 October.
The prisoners of 17 October have called on us to do just that. To heed their call would be to give the word ‘solidarity’ a deeper meaning:
‘If we want to see the end of the Macron era and of this regime he still dares to call the Republic, we must bring all our forces together. Blockades, riots, demonstrations, strikes, battles in the media and against institutions: these are all paths we must take together, united and in great numbers.’
Conclusion: Carrying 17 October Forward
‘Some things need to be done properly, so let's do them…’ — Makala, Action Film
One thing has been conspicuously absent from this text until now: 17 October. I am writing because, first, I do not consider 17 October part of the youth movement, and second, because the past three weeks have failed to match the strength displayed on that day.
None of the criticisms made above apply to what happened on 17 October. It was a day of insurrection in which different groups took part in the same event without pursuing the same objectives. This diversity wreaked havoc across France and defeated the police. We must reckon with that too. Above all, we must affirm that we were there.
The autonomous movement is part of the movement now unfolding, and one of the reasons for the success of the 17th. But it is not the only part, and the day's success did not come from other sections of society suddenly beginning to ‘act autonomously’. Quite the contrary. The 17th neither vindicates nor refutes our position. The different logics at work cannot all be subsumed under the signifier ‘insurrection’.
There are people who cheerfully loot shops and will vote for Mélenchon; there are trade unionists; there are people who organise to make money and accept the criminal character of their activities. Among those who wanted to enter the Élysée Palace were former Yellow Vests, autonomists and the most traditional contingents of left-wing parties. Yet for a brief moment, the question was no longer one of youth or solidarity.
What we experienced on the 17th was what Phil A. Neel calls the ‘historical party’ and Marx the ‘party of anarchy’:
‘We have seen, little by little, the peasants, the petty bourgeoisie and the middle classes in general rally to the side of the proletariat, driven into open opposition against the official Republic, which treats them as adversaries.’
It is this particular constellation that we are struggling to recreate. The question, it seems to me, is how to give this heterogeneity a place within our forms of organisation. We cannot pretend that the 17th never happened. But neither can we expect events to unfold in precisely the same way again. We need to create something in the intervals between demonstrations, between the moments we hope will become insurrectionary.
The collective problem we face at this stage is how to recover the conflict and heterogeneity we experienced on the 17th. For weeks now we have been hoping to do so, yet the trap seems only to tighten around us. The reflex of offering support is part of this trap, but so is the routine of activism.
It seems to me that we must begin by analysing our own strength. The way out of this impasse lies in combining the approach the schoolchildren have shown us with the recognition that, in the specific European context, older people are also revolutionary subjects. This opens up some exciting questions. What would be the equivalent, for teachers, railway workers, farmers and pensioners, of setting off a mortar at school between two ‘aura battles’? At this stage I find it difficult to suggest concrete courses of action. But there is, I think, a somewhat more joyful way of asking ourselves what is to be done.
Finally, we must recognise that ‘the 17th’ also obliges us to open ourselves up to other currents within the ongoing revolt, engaging with them not in solidarity but as accomplices. The task ahead is clear. We must find forms of organisation that allow us to come together and strengthen one another without erasing our social, racial, political and ethical differences, on the basis of a shared experience: that of the 17th — which is to say, the belief in revolution.
We have spread anarchy. All that remains is to live communism.